Astronomy and Astrophysics Spectroscopic Investigation of Old Planetaries v. Distance Scales
نویسنده
چکیده
We use the results of our recent NLTE model atmosphere analysis of central stars of old planetary nebulae (PN) to calculate distances. We perform a comparison with three other methods (trigonometric parallaxes, interstellar NaD lines, and Shklovsky distances) and discuss the problem of the PNe distance scale. The result of the comparison of our spectroscopic distances with the trigonometric distances is that the spectroscopic distances are 55% larger. Since using trigonometric parallaxes with large relative measurement errors can introduce systematic errors, we carried out a Monte Carlo simulation of the biases introduced by selection effects and measurement errors. It turns out that a difference between both distance scales of the observed size is expected for the present day data if the underlying distance scales are identical. Thus our finding is essentially a confirmation of the spectroscopic distance scale! Good agreement is found between the spectroscopic distances and distances derived from the interstellar NaD lines. All three independent methods of distance measurement indicate that the widely used “statistical” distance scales of the Shklovsky type are too short for old PNe. A correlation with nebular radii exists. The most likely explanation is an underestimate of the nebula masses for large PN. Implications for the nebula masses are discussed. Estimates of the PNe space density and birthrate, which are based on Shklovsky type distances, therefore give too large values.
منابع مشابه
Spectroscopic investigation of old planetaries V . Distance scales
We use the results of our recent NLTE model atmosphere analysis of central stars of old planetary nebulae (PN) to calculate distances. We perform a comparison with three other methods (trigonometric parallaxes, interstellar NaD lines, and Shklovsky distances) and discuss the problem of the PNe distance scale. The result of the comparison of our spectroscopic distances with the trigonometric dis...
متن کاملClose Binaries as the Progenitors of the Brightest Planetary Nebulae
We investigate the possible progenitors of the planetary nebulae (PNs) which populate the top 0.5 mag of the [O III] λ5007 planetary nebula luminosity function (PNLF). We show that the absolute luminosity of the PNLF cutoff demands that the central stars of these most luminous planetaries be & 0.6M⊙, and that such high-mass PN cores must exist in every galaxy. We also use the bolometricluminosi...
متن کاملA Novel Color Parameter As A Luminosity Calibrator for Type Ia Supernovae
Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) provide us with a unique tool for measuring extragalactic distances and determining cosmological parameters. As a result, the precise and effective calibration for peak luminosities of SNe Ia becomes extremely crucial and thus is critically scrutinized for cosmological explorations. In this Letter, we reveal clear evidence for a tight linear correlation between peak ...
متن کاملOn the distances of planetary nebulæ
Reconsidering calibration of statistical distance scales for planetary nebulæ leads naturally to examining precision and especially the systematic errors of other methods. Here we present a different calibration strategy based on the precise trigonometric parallaxes for sixteen central stars published by Harris et al. (2007) of USNO, with four improved by Benedict et al. using the Hubble Space ...
متن کامل